Vintage loudspeakers
Article was published in Hi Fi World April 2014 edition
Buying speakers is always tricky but when it comes to vintage models not only is the choice bewildering, other factors come into play. So let Adam Smith be your guide...

It was in 1924 that Chester Rice and Edward Kellog patented the direct radiator moving-coil loudspeaker drive unit. While other technologies have attempted to muscle in on the action with varying degrees of success, the drive units found in the vast majority of loudspeakers on the market today are still based on the very same technology the pair outlined 90 years ago. Of course, materials have grown more high-tech, driver shapes and sizes have changed and computers have aided designers in attaining the sort of performance that Rice and Kellog could only have dreamed of. But the basic principle remains the same.

One result of these many decades of development is that there is a huge range of loudspeakers of all shapes and sizes to consider when assembling a vintage system. For the purposes of this feature, however, the story really begins in the 1960s when the increasing adoption of stereo led to the development of freestanding loudspeakers. Many audiophiles of the pre-stereo era purchased drive units which they then housed in radiogram-style cabinets, sideboards and even the walls of rooms where convenience was the sole determining factor. But the move to

RIGHT: The corner reflex cabinet was one of the enclosures recommended byTannoyas being 'suitable for high quality Phonograph and Radio repros'. The Comer York was one of the first compducing systemlete assemblies offered by the company. To the right Is shown a Tannoy Monitor Black driver and below, an original Japanese ad for the Cold driver
BELOW: The driver of a modem Tannoyspeaker (in this case, the Kensington) bears a strong resemblance to the original Monitor Black. Materials have improved and the design has been fine-tuned over the years

two channels necessitated optimal loudspeaker positioning, which was much easier with freestanding enclosures. Of course, fine designs of this type existed previously, such as Voigt's Domestic Corner Horn and Quad's Ribbon loudspeaker, but the fact that these models were developed and sold when mono was the only option means that finding pairs of such examples on the secondhand market today can be very difficult. As for matched pairs, this can be nigh on impossible.

One of the most successful companies to bridge the gap between individual drive units and complete loudspeaker assemblies was Tannoy. Its Dual Concentric drive unit was developed in 1946 by engineer Ronnie Rackham and the 15in Monitor Black was the first model to hit the market. This was duly developed into a bewildering range of Monitor Red, Silver and Cold models of many different sizes, but in the mid 1960s the company released the Lancaster free-standing cabinet and the York corner cabinet, which both used the 15in Monitor Red drive unit. The flagship Monitor Cold came a little later, with its natural home being the mighty Autograph cabinet.

Tannoy loudspeakers have a huge following among vintage audio enthusiasts and it is not difficult to understand why when you hear a pair in good working order. They have a sound all of their own, with excellent imagery being just one of their strengths. Most original speakers are serviceable by specialist companies and replacement surrounds and cones for many models are available, making them a viable secondhand proposition. Prices tend to be high for original models in good condition but there are plenty about, so choice is not an issue. Back on the other side of the Atlantic, developments in loudspeaker cabinet design

were also underway during hi-fi's formative years and one of the most notable resulted in the Acoustic Suspension loudspeaker, developed by Henry Kloss and Edgar Villchur at Acoustic Research. This type of loudspeaker meant that smaller cabinets could be used that would also deliver good bass response. The result was the AR-1, released in the mid 1950s, followed by the AR-3 in 1958, which employed the AR-1's 12in bass driver in conjunction with the first commercially available dome midrange driver and tweeter. The AR-3 was regarded as one of the finest loudspeakers of its era and, thanks to its groundbreaking design, can more than hold its own today. The drivers are generally robust provided they are not overdriven and a pair in good condition can sound superb when suitably partnered.

The acoustic suspension design became very popular in the 1960s and 1970s and spawned many successful models. Perhaps one of the most important back in the UK was the original Goodmans Maxim of 1965, which can be regarded as the first mini-monitor to bring true high fidelity performance to a cabinet that could be sat on an upturned hand (but only just - they're surprisingly heavy!). Even the BBC evaluated an early pair and judged the performance to be 'adequate for a number of applications in which high sound levels are unnecessary'. While it's true the speaker lacks any meaningful amount of deep

ABOVE LEFT: The AR Pi One is the speaker that superseded the AR-3. It featured the same basic technology but added room boundary adjustment controls. It is very rare today
ABOVE: The AR-3 built upon the AR-1 Acoustic Suspension concept, adding a midrange dome unit to the 12in bass driver and dome tweeter
BELOW: The original tiny tot with the big heart -the Goodmans Maxim minimonitor, which appeared in 1965

bass and requires more than a modicum of power to perform at its best, the original Maxim is a remarkable loudspeaker even by modern standards and prices continue to rise. Its driver surrounds are not made of foam so have good longevity, but the plastic edging of the tweeter cone has a tendency to come unstuck from the chassis, so check this carefully if you're considering buying a pair.

At this time, work was continuing not only on cabinet design but also on the materials from which drive units were made. Paper had always been popular due to its cheapness, lightness and relatively benign break-up behaviour but 1961 saw a breakthrough when Leak introduced its 'Sandwich' loudspeaker cone, developed by Don Barlow. This saw a layer of polystyrene sandwiched between

'To hear a good pair of Leak 3090s is a magnificent experience'

The biggest killer of old loudspeakers is 'foam rot' - the breaking down of the foam ring that supports the cone at its periphery. Replacement rings are available from many sources at very reasonable prices and fitting them is not difficult, although several companies will do the job for you if you prefer. Note that continuing to use a loudspeaker with a rotten surround is likely to damage the voice coil so beware of 'they still sound fine' when buyingl Also remember that component and wire quality has improved greatly since the 1960s and benefits may be wrought by re-wiring and replacing crossover components in old loudspeakers, particularly the capacitors.

two layers of aluminium which conferred exceptional rigidity upon the cone without affecting strength or adding undue mass. The first complete Leak Sandwich loudspeaker used a 13in bass driver of this construction allied to a 3in high frequency driver, and even today the speakers deliver a delightful, if somewhat soft and unfocused listening experience. Cloth driver surrounds mean no foam rot and although the drivers can 'sag' after many years' use, resulting in a rubbing voice coil, the magnet on these early drivers was bolted on, so a steady hand can loosen the whole motor assembly and adjust it to compensate. The range of loudspeakers using the Sandwich technology grew and diversified during the 1960s and 1970s to culminate in the mighty Leak 3090. This utilised a 15in Sandwich bass driver in a transmission line, plus two Sandwich midrange drivers and an Isodynamic ribbon tweeter. They're huge, not exactly elegant, the tweeters are somewhat fragile and they need plenty of power to drive them but

to hear a good pair of 3090s is a cabinet magnificent experience and possibly the ultimate expression of the teak vastness of 1970s loudspeakers! Sadly, relatively few pairs were made and they are quite rare. However, their predecessor, the Leak 2075, is very similar, more common and can be bought more cheaply. These also perform well but their Mylar dome tweeter is an altogether less civilised proposition. Using modern capacitors in the crossover does bring noticeable improvements in this area, however. As mentioned, over the years a number of other technologies have tried to rob the moving-coil drive unit of its crown and one of the most successful has been the electrostatic loudspeaker. The Quad Electrostatic Loudspeaker of 1957 (subsequently known as the ESL-57)

was the first successful model and this was replaced by the ESL-63 in the early 1980s. While the original ESL is a fine performer, it does have limitations when it comes to power handling and bass output due to the use of different panels to cover different areas of the frequency range

The ESL-63 takes a different approach, using multiple concentric rings through which the audio signal passes from inner to outer, with suitable delays applied electronically. The net result is that the loudspeaker generates an image with similar properties to that of a point-source located behind the panel. This in turn gives a phasecoherent signal and an absence of treble 'beaming' due to the large area involved. Further improvements mean that the ESL-63 is also more tolerant of being overdriven, thanks to a better protection circuit. Despite this, the ESL-63 has a tendency to be overlooked in favour of its more famous predecessor, or the even more technologically advanced models like the ESL- 989 that came after. As a result, prices are not as high as might be expected, especially for the quality of sound on offer. Quad still offers full service facilities for this model, so there is very little reason not to snap up a pair of ESL-63s if you fancy experiencing the sound of an electrostatic loudspeaker.

ABOVE: The Leak Sandwich and its 'mini' variant (right). The mini used an oval bass/ midrange driver in a more compact to hear a good pair of 3090s is a cabinet
ERR LEFT: A cutaway of the full-size Sandwich model shows the cone construction, plus the fixing of the driver magnet to the rear panel
BELOW LEFT: The very first panel design-the Quad Electrostatic from 1957
BELOW: Quad's ESL-63 took the electrostatic concept a level higher while Magnepan's MG-1 (right) was another alternative to the traditional loudspeaker
'There is very little reason not to snap up a pair of Quad ESL-63s'

Other panel loudspeakers have also met with considerable success over the years and one of the most interesting was the planar loudspeaker developed by Jim Winey of Magnepan in 1969. This design took the form of a large number of thin conductive wires on a Mylar panel suspended in a magnetic field arising from a vertical array of magnets. The whole sheet moves in a similar manner to that of a conventional loudspeaker unit but the wires are directly attached to the radiating surface and the loudspeaker behaves as a dipole. In other words, like an electrostatic but without the need for the high voltages.

The company's first loudspeaker of this type was the MG-1 of 1976 and development has continued to the present day. The benefits of such designs are similar to those of electrostatics, namely superb imagery and coherence, but Magnepan also added ribbon tweeters to many of its later models to improve treble response. Deep bass can also be an issue due to

the sheer size of panel needed if this is to be achieved. Despite this, original MG-ls can perform very well indeed and have a dedicated following. Tweeter fuses can blow giving rise to a dullness in sound and the exposed aluminium wires on the drive panel can corrode and break. These can be repaired, however, albeit with patience and a steady pair of hands.

As the industry moved into the 1980s, cabinets shrank once more and designers continued tc experiment with driver construction and cabinet configuration. The likes of the Epos ES14, with its plastic-coned bass/midrange driver and metal dome tweeter, provided a recipe that would endure throughout the 'flat-earth' years of the decade. However, the speaker that stood head and shoulders above the rest was made by Celestion and called the SL6. This speaker marked the first major use of laser interferometry to analyse drive unit behaviour and was also the first loudspeaker to feature a copper metal dome tweeter. This was followed by the SL600 with its 'honeycomb' cabinet made of Aerolam. The result were loudspeakers with outstanding clarity and class-leading dynamics.

Unfortunately, both designs were difficult to drive, had no deep bass to speak of and a surprising lack of crispness at the top end, treble rolling off quite early due to the weight of the copper tweeter dome. Later variants of both models saw aluminium used for the tweeter dome, which alleviated the treble issues while the superb dipole SL6000 subwoofer was introduced to add extra bass. The latter remains a much sought-after classic in its own right (it works well with Quad ESL-63s, tool) but, despite their advanced design, sonically the SL6 and SL600 remain truly 'Marmite' loudspeakers: you'll either love them or hate theml

A final mention should be given to active loudspeakers. Although companies like ARC, JPW and Linn marketed versions of their models in the early 1980s that could be driven by amplifiers equipped with suitable electronic crossovers, the only companies to dedicate themselves fully to active operation were Meridian and Bang & Olufsen. The former's M1 loudspeaker of 1978 was an undoubted statement of intent and was followed by smaller designs such as the M2 and M3, plus even more impressive flagships such as the Ml 00. Reliability of all these models is excellent and they still sound superb today. Only rarity and price conspire against the keen buyer.

ABOVE: The Celestion SL6 of 1982 made novel use of plastic and copper in its construction, plus computerdriven laser measurement techniques in its design. It made the cover of the February 1982 issue of HFN with a review inside by Trevor Attewell
LEFT: The Meridian Ml was the company's first loudspeaker and brought active operation to the mainstream market Hidden beneath its somewhat monolithic exterior is a bass driver with a rearmounted Auxiliary Bass Radiator, an ITT dome midrange and a KEF dome tweeter. The amplifier and electronic crossover box sit on a shelf in the base of the speaker behind the grille

ALSO CONSIDER... BBC LS3/5A: Famous mini broadcast monitor made by many manufacturers including Rogers, KEF and Goodmans. Has a unique blend of strengths, some of which remain unsurpassed even today. IMF Professional Monitor: A big 1970s bruiser with a KEF B139 bass driver in a transmission line. Super bass and a big, relaxed presentation. Apogee Scintilla: Fine-sounding full-size ribbon panel design but dubbed the 'amp killer' by many due to its lohm minimum electrical load. Make sure your amplifier is up to the task.

B&W 801: One of the best passive studio monitoring speakers ever [pictured above], Discontinued during the company's last upgrade of the 800 series to 'Diamond' status. Greatly missed! TDL Reference Standard: Produced some of the lowest and finest bass to be heard from any domestic loudspeaker. Very big and very rare. Mission 767: Unassuming looks hide first-class design giving a fabulous sound. Make sure they come with their Cyrus 2-based 'LFAU' bass tuning/amp unit. Monitor Audio R352: Affordable 1980s large standmount. Matching stands not the best sonically but they just don't look right sat on anything elsel Goodmans Maxim 2: Budget '80s bookshelf design that is absurdly good for something that originally cost £70.